Discover Broadway's Latest Celebrations and Star Highlights on August 11, 2025

Celebrate Star Power: Mamma Mia's Notable Performers Past and Present

Update Rediscovering Mamma Mia: The Stars Who Shone Bright As the iconic musical Mamma Mia! makes its much-anticipated return to Broadway, audiences are eager to revisit the beloved story filled with the timeless music of ABBA. But beyond its catchy tunes and charming plot lies a fascinating history of talented performers who have graced its stage. Let’s take a moment to explore some of the impressive stars who have played pivotal roles in various productions of Mamma Mia! around the globe. A Star-Studded History The return of Mamma Mia! to the Winter Garden Theatre is a perfect occasion to reflect on the myriad of talent that has participated in this production. The original Broadway production debuted in 2001 and has since seen many well-known figures take on lead roles, enriching the show with their unique styles and performances. The Versatile Carolee Carmello One of the standout performers tied to Mamma Mia! is Carolee Carmello, who has played the role of Donna on multiple occasions since 2004. A celebrated Broadway actress, Carmello has earned three Tony Award nominations and a Drama Desk Award for her work, showcasing her extensive theatrical talents in shows like Parade, Tuck Everlasting, and Finding Neverland. The Country Star: Jennifer Nettles Another noteworthy name is Jennifer Nettles, lead vocalist of the Grammy-winning duo Sugarland. She took the stage as Donna during a star-studded 2017 Hollywood Bowl production, where she shared the limelight with performers like Corbin Bleu and Dove Cameron. The crossover from country music to Broadway demonstrated Nettles' versatility as an artist. International Talent: Willemijn Verkaik In a remarkable international twist, Willemijn Verkaik, known for her portrayal of Elphaba in the German production of Wicked, took on the role of Donna in Stuttgart. This showcases the global reach of Mamma Mia!, reflecting how the musical resonates across different cultures and languages. Another Elphaba: Julia Murney Julia Murney, another Broadway star, known for her portrayal of Elphaba, also featured in Mamma Mia! as Donna. Her experience within the theatrical world, including nominations for Drama Desk Awards, highlights the caliber of talent associated with this production. A Bold Rosie: Lea DeLaria Lea DeLaria brought her unique flair to the role of Rosie in the Hollywood Bowl show, further extending the reach and appeal of Mamma Mia!. With her background in both theater and television, notably in Orange Is the New Black, DeLaria exemplifies the diverse backgrounds and influences of the performers that enrich this musical. Final Thoughts All these stars share a common passion for theater, proving that Mamma Mia! isn't just a musical; it's a formidable platform for artistic expression that connects multi-talented individuals through the universal language of music. As audiences gather to enjoy this show once again, they are not just witnessing a performance—they are part of a legacy of talent that has shaped Broadway over the years. This revival not only celebrates its theatrical feats but serves as a reminder that musicals like Mamma Mia! forever hold a special place in our hearts.